Board Games Mystery [9 BEST Whodunnit Games]

BOARD GAMES MYSTERY: See the [9 BEST Whodunnit Games] in our mystery games list! *SEE NOW* Browse the best mystery board games on Amazon in our murder board game toys feature!

***SCROLL DOWN FOR MORE...

Last update on 2019-12-15 at 08:11 Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Our Top Recommendation

Hasbro Clue Board Game - The Classic Mystery
531 Reviews
Hasbro Clue Board Game - The Classic Mystery
  • In this suspenseful Clue game, players have to find out who's responsible for murdering Mr. Boddy of Tudor Mansion...
  • Introducing a new character, Dr. Orchid as one of the suspects
  • Includes: 1 gameboard, 6 tokens, 6 miniature weapons, 30 Cards (6 character cards, 6 weapon cards, 9 room cards,...

Last update on 2019-12-15 at 08:11 Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

What is a mystery board game?

How are these games played?

Are they fun for adults and kids both?

A mystery board game isn’t quite the same thing as a horror board game, although there’s plenty of overlap between the two. Mystery games are all about solving the mystery and finding out “whodunnit” before the other players—or sometimes working along with the other players instead.

In some instances, the solution may be less about a culprit and more about a cure or a means to escape. Still, no matter what the end result may be, players must collect clues and uncover secrets to help them figure it all out.

These games are great for both adults and kids, although some horror mysteries may be too scary for the younger members of the family.

Read on to find out about some board games mystery fans are sure to love.

#1: Ultimate Werewolf

Bezier Games Ultimate Werewolf Deluxe Edition

In Ultimate Werewolf, players are assigned the role of either Werewolf or Villager. From there, they can be narrowed down into unique personalities and character types using the included cards. Teams must work against each other to solve the mystery and win the game.

Pros

  • This game can be enjoyed by up to 75 players, so it’s great for massive parties.
  • The game is easy to learn.

Cons

  • The game has some mature themes (such as mentions of suicide) that may not be appropriate for kids.
  • The cards are not very durable.

#2: Clue

Hasbro Clue Board Game - The Classic Mystery

Clue is the classic murder mystery family game that almost everyone is sure to recognize. This game involves players investigating on their own and working against each other to try to figure out who committed the murder. Hints are given as players progress throughout the game board, which is non-linear.

Pros

  • It doesn’t take long to set up or get the hang of this game, even for new players.
  • The game can be enjoyed by kids and adults together.

Cons

  • The updated version of Clue contains poor quality game components.
  • The game has been made much easier than the classic version, with many customers finding it too easy.

#3: The Secret Door

Mystery Board Game The Secret Door by Family Pastimes - Award Winning

The Secret Door is a game that’s perfect for groups of kids who want to have their own mystery to solve. This game requires working together cooperatively on teams to figure out how to open the door and learn what’s behind it. Up to eight kids can play this game together.

Pros

  • This game is made with eco-friendly materials and keeps the environment in mind.
  • The game may have a spooky theme, but it isn’t scary for little one at all.

Cons

  • The game is very easy and intended for young kids only.
  • The game pieces are small, light, and may be lost easily.

#4: 13 Dead End Drive

13 Dead End Drive

In 13 Dead End Drive, players work against each other to solve the mystery while tricking each other along the way. The game involves keeping identities secret and only playing certain cards when the time is right to get rid of another player.

Pros

  • This game is perfect for 2 to 4 players and for ages 8 and up, so it’s great for family game night.
  • The game is a faithful reproduction of the 1990s version.

Cons

  • Assembly of the game board may take some time.
  • There are a lot of moving parts and quite a lot of luck involved, so this game can be unpredictable.

#5: Deception: Murder in Hong Kong

Grey Fox Games Deception: Murder in Hong Kong Board Game

In Deception: Murder in Hong Kong, players must guard their own secrets while trying to figure out what happened. Players take on different roles, including the murderer, the accomplice, the witness, the investigator, and the forensic scientist. This game involves a lot of discussion between the different players and their roles.

Pros

  • This game can be enjoyed by as few as 4 or up to 12 players.
  • The game is quick and can be completed in 20 to 30 minutes in most instances.

Cons

  • Some roles may be a lot more boring to play than others.
  • The game may be very challenging to keep track of as it progresses.

#6: 221B Baker Street

Deluxe 221B Baker Street Board Game - 200 Intriguing Adventures 2-6 Players

In 221B Baker Street, players move across the board and uncover hints and clues to help them deduce the solution to the mystery. This game involves several different adventures that can be played on the same board and with the same pieces, so gameplay can be varied from time to time.

Pros

  • The included game pieces are good quality.
  • The game involves solving riddles, which is a different take on the mystery game.

Cons

  • The game is challenging for kids and may be best for adults only.
  • The product may arrive missing several cards.

#7: Letters from Whitechapel

Letters from Whitechapel

Keep things creepy with the horror mystery game Letters from Whitechapel. This game is based on the true story of Jack the Ripper and pits one player against the others in a cat-and-mouse type challenge. The murderer character must try to escape without being caught, and the detectives must work together to try to figure out where he’s going next.

Pros

  • This game involves unique play mechanics that are easy to learn.
  • The game is as much fun for 2 players as it is for a group.

Cons

  • This game has many mature themes and is not intended for children.
  • The game can be extremely repetitive.

#8: Mysterium

Mysterium

Mysterium is a ghost-themed mystery game with horror elements as well. This game is not as scary as many other horror mysteries, however, since it’s intended for kids as well as adults to enjoy together. Either everyone loses or everyone wins in this cooperative adventure.

Pros

  • This game can be enjoyed by two to four players and by ages ten and up.
  • The game can be completed in less than an hour, so it’s good for family game night.

Cons

  • Since it’s designed for kids as well, some adults may find this game too easy or boring.
  • The product may arrive damaged or missing parts.

#9: Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective

Asmodee Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Game

Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective is based on the mysteries of the Sherlock Holmes novels, with a twist. Players work on their own to try to solve the mysteries before the other players—and before Sherlock himself can figure them out, too. Each clue leads players in a new direction and can be used to help narrow down the solution.

Pros

  • This game has won awards for its quality and mechanics.
  • The game can be enjoyed solo or by up to 8 players.

Cons

  • This is a re-released edition which may have some typos and printing issues.
  • The font on the cards is hard for some players to read.

Conclusion

Did you find a board game you want to try? These mystery games are ideal for groups who want to enjoy their time at a party either working together or against each other to reach the solution. They may also be good for family game nights, but they may get redundant in this situation when players start to figure things out too quickly. Keep this in mind when choosing from the great board games above!

OUR TOP PICK?