How to Sell Board Games: 13 Ways To Boost Your Profits

Introduction

Selling board games can be a great way to make some extra cash or declutter your home. In this article, we will provide you with information on the best places and methods to sell board games. We’ll also discuss important factors to consider that influence resale price, such as condition, original MSRP, rarity and more. This way you can ensure that you are ready with the knowledge needed to get the best price for your games. Whether you’re looking to sell online or locally, there are many options available to you. So, let’s dive in and explore the world of selling board games!

Factors that Influence Resale Price

When it comes to selling board games, there are several factors that can influence the resale price. By considering these factors, sellers can determine the best price for their board games and maximize their profits.

Let’s take a closer look at each of these factors below:

🎲 – Importance of condition in determining value: The condition of a board game is one of the most important factors in determining its resale value. Games that are in excellent condition, with no missing pieces and minimal wear and tear, will typically sell for a higher price than games that are damaged or incomplete.

💰 – Original MSRP and its impact on resale price: The original manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP) of a board game can also have an impact on its resale value. Games that were originally priced higher will typically sell for a higher price on the secondary market, even if they are now out of print.

📈 – Demand and its effect on resale value: The level of demand for a particular board game can also have a significant impact on its resale value. Games that are currently popular or in high demand will typically sell for a higher price than games that are less popular or have fallen out of favor.

🦄 – Rarity and its influence on value: Finally, the rarity of a board game can also have a significant impact on its resale value. Games that are rare or hard to find will typically sell for a higher price than games that are readily available. This is especially true for games that are out of print and no longer being produced.

By taking these factors into consideration, you can better understand how to price and sell your board games for the best possible resale value.

Best Places to Sell Board Games Online

When it comes to selling board games, there are plenty of options available both online and locally. For those looking to sell online, we’ve got a great round-up of ideas here to get you started. It’s important to consider the condition, original MSRP, demand, and rarity of the board game when determining its value and choosing the best place to sell it.

Option #1. Amazon FBA

Learn how to sell gameboards using Amazon FBA

What You Need:

• A seller account on Amazon
• Board games to sell
• Shipping rpg-supplies-stores/">supplies (boxes, tape, labels)

Step-By-Step:

1. List your board games for sale on Amazon, making sure to accurately describe the condition and any other relevant details.
2. Once your items sell, package them securely using appropriate shipping supplies.
3. Print the shipping label provided by Amazon and affix it to the package.
4. Drop off the package at a designated shipping location or schedule a pickup with the carrier.

Things To Know:

• Amazon FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) allows you to store your inventory in Amazon’s warehouses and have them handle the shipping and customer service for you.
• This can be a convenient and efficient way to sell board games, as Amazon has a large customer base and handles many of the logistical aspects of selling.
• However, it’s important to factor in the fees associated with using Amazon FBA, as they can cut into your profits.
• Additionally, it’s important to properly package your items to avoid damage during shipping and to accurately describe the condition of your items to avoid any issues with customer satisfaction.

Option #2. eBay

Learn how to sell gameboards using eBay

What You Need:

• A computer or mobile device with internet access
• A valid eBay account
• A camera or smartphone to take photos of your board games
• Packaging materials such as boxes, bubble wrap, and tape

Step-By-Step:

1. Create a listing for your board game by clicking on the “Sell” button on the eBay homepage.
2. Choose the category and subcategory that best fits your board game.
3. Write a clear and detailed title for your listing that includes the name of the board game and any important details such as the edition or condition.
4. Take clear and well-lit photos of your board game from multiple angles and upload them to your listing.
5. Write a detailed description of your board game that includes any flaws or damage, the age range, and the number of players.
6. Set a price for your board game and choose whether you want to offer free shipping or charge for shipping separately.
7. Choose the duration of your listing and any additional options such as a reserve price or a buy-it-now option.
8. Monitor your listing and respond promptly to any questions or offers from potential buyers.
9. Once your board game sells, package it carefully and ship it promptly to the buyer.

Things To Know:

• Be honest and transparent about the condition of your board game in your listing description to avoid any disputes with buyers.
• Consider offering free shipping or a discounted shipping rate to make your listing more attractive to buyers.
• Research the prices of similar board games on eBay to ensure that you are pricing your board game competitively.
• Consider offering a bundle deal if you have multiple board games to sell to attract more buyers.

Option #3. BoardGameGeek (Geek Market)

Learn how to sell gameboards on BoardGameGeek (Geek Market)

What You Need:

• Board games to sell
• A BoardGameGeek account
• A PayPal account (optional)

Step-By-Step:

1. Log in to your BoardGameGeek account and navigate to the Geek Market section.
2. Click on the “Sell” button and fill out the required information about the board game you want to sell, including the condition, price, and shipping options.
3. Upload pictures of the board game to give potential buyers a better idea of its condition.
4. Wait for interested buyers to contact you through the messaging system on BoardGameGeek.
5. Once a buyer has agreed to purchase the board game, arrange payment and shipping details. You can use PayPal for a secure transaction if both parties agree.

Things To Know:

• Be honest about the condition of the board game to avoid any issues with the buyer.
• Consider offering free shipping or a discount for multiple purchases to attract more buyers.
• Respond to messages from potential buyers in a timely manner to show that you are a reliable seller.

Option #4. Facebook Marketplace

Learn how to sell gameboards using Facebook Marketplace.

What You Need:

• A Facebook account
• A device with internet access
• High-quality photos of the board games you want to sell

Step-By-Step:

1. Log in to your Facebook account and navigate to the Marketplace section.
2. Click on the “Sell Something” button and select “Item for Sale.”
3. Choose the category “Toys & Games” and enter the details of the board game you want to sell, including the title, price, and condition.
4. Upload high-quality photos of the board game from different angles.
5. Write a detailed description of the board game, including any special features or components.
6. Set your preferred payment and delivery options.
7. Click “Post” to publish your listing.

Things To Know:

• Be honest about the condition of the board game to avoid any disputes with buyers.
• Respond promptly to any inquiries or messages from potential buyers.
• Consider offering bundle deals or discounts for multiple board games to attract more buyers.

Option #5. Noble Knight Games

Learn how to sell gameboards on Noble Knight Games

What You Need:

• A Noble Knight Games account
• Board games to sell
• Accurate and detailed descriptions of the board games

Step-By-Step:

1. Log in to your Noble Knight Games account.
2. Click on the “Sell to Us” tab.
3. Select the category of board games you want to sell.
4. Enter the title and condition of the board game.
5. Provide a detailed description of the board game, including any missing pieces or damage.
6. Enter the price you want to sell the board game for.
7. Submit the form and wait for Noble Knight Games to review your submission.
8. If Noble Knight Games accepts your submission, they will send you a confirmation email with instructions on how to ship the board game to them.
9. Ship the board game to Noble Knight Games using the provided instructions.
10. . Once Noble Knight Games receives the board game and confirms its condition, they will pay you the agreed-upon price.

Things To Know:

• Noble Knight Games only accepts board games in good condition.
• It is important to accurately describe the condition of the board game to ensure a fair price.
• Noble Knight Games may offer a lower price than what you initially requested, so be prepared to negotiate.

Option #6. Reddit groups

Learn how to sell gameboards using Reddit Groups

What You Need:

• A Reddit account
• A list of relevant board game subreddits
• High-quality photos of the board games you want to sell

Step-By-Step:

1. Find relevant board game subreddits by searching for keywords such as “board games for sale” or “board game marketplace.”
2. Read the rules of each subreddit carefully to ensure that you are following their guidelines for selling board games.
3. Create a post with a clear and descriptive title, including the name of the game and its condition.
4. Include high-quality photos of the game, including any damage or wear and tear.
5. Set a fair price for the game, taking into account its condition, rarity, and market value.
6. Respond promptly to any inquiries or offers from potential buyers.
7. Once you have agreed on a price with a buyer, arrange for payment and shipping.

Things To Know:

• Be honest about the condition of the game in your post and photos.
• Consider offering discounts for bulk purchases or combined shipping.
• Respond to comments and messages in a timely manner to build trust with potential buyers.
• Be aware of any fees or commissions that may be charged by Reddit or payment platforms such as PayPal.

Option #7. Board game trading group on Facebook

Learn how to sell gameboards in a Facebook Trading Group

What You Need:

• A Facebook account
• A list of the board games you want to sell
• Clear photos of the board games
• A fair price for each board game

Step-By-Step:

1. Join a board game trading group on Facebook. You can search for these groups by typing “board game trading” in the Facebook search bar.
2. Once you have been accepted into the group, create a post with the list of board games you want to sell. Make sure to include clear photos of each board game.
3. Set a fair price for each board game. You can research the prices of similar board games on websites like eBay or Amazon to get an idea of what a fair price would be.
4. Be responsive to potential buyers. Answer any questions they may have about the board games and negotiate prices if necessary.
5. Once you have agreed on a price with a buyer, arrange for payment and shipping.

Things To Know:

• Be honest about the condition of the board games. If there are any missing pieces or damage, make sure to disclose this information in your post.
• Don’t be afraid to negotiate prices with potential buyers. It’s better to sell the board game for a slightly lower price than to not sell it at all.
• Make sure to package the board games carefully when shipping them to the buyer to avoid any damage during transit.
• Respond to inquiries and messages promptly to show that you are a reliable seller.
• Consider offering a discount for multiple board games purchased to encourage buyers to purchase more than one game.

Best Places to Sell Board Games In Your Local Community

Selling board games can be a lucrative business, whether you’re selling new or used games, and you don’t have to go too far from your own community to get started. No matter which business style you choose to start with, make sure to do some research in your own locale and start maximizing your profits without leaving the comfort of your own neighborhood.

Option #8. Garage sales

Learn how to sell gameboards at Garage Sales

What You Need:

• Board games to sell
• A table or surface to display the games
• Price tags or stickers

Step-By-Step:

1. Sort through your board games and decide which ones you want to sell.
2. Clean and organize the games to make them look presentable.
3. Set up a table or surface to display the games.
4. Price each game individually using price tags or stickers.
5. During the garage sale, be friendly and approachable to potential buyers.
6. Be willing to negotiate on prices if necessary.

Things To Know:

• Consider grouping similar games together to make it easier for buyers to find what they’re looking for.
• Make sure to have enough change on hand to make transactions easier.
• If possible, advertise your garage sale in advance to attract more potential buyers.

Option #9. Board Game & Hobby Stores

Learn how to sell gameboards at Board Game & Hobby Stores

What You Need:

• Your board games to sell
• Knowledge of the board games you are selling
• A friendly and approachable attitude

Step-By-Step:

1. Research the board game and hobby stores in your area. Look for stores that specialize in board games and have a good reputation.
2. Visit the stores and introduce yourself to the staff. Let them know that you have board games to sell and ask if they are interested in purchasing them.
3. Show the staff your board games and provide them with any necessary information about the games, such as the age range, number of players, and game mechanics.
4. Negotiate a fair price for your board games with the staff. Be willing to compromise and consider their expertise in the industry.
5. If the store agrees to purchase your board games, make sure to provide them with any additional information they may need, such as instructions or promotional materials.

Things To Know:

• Be prepared to answer any questions the staff may have about your board games.
• Consider offering a discount or bundle deal if the store purchases multiple games from you.
• Remember that the staff at board game and hobby stores are experts in their field, so be open to their advice and suggestions.

PRO TIP: Inquire about an annual used sale day

Does your local game store’s have an upcoming annual used sale day? Make the most out of this event and consider crafting eye-catching displays in order to negotiate prices with customers. These types of occasions are great opportunities that will have a ton of avid tabletop gamers around to check out your offers.

What You Need:

• Board games you want to sell
• Price tags or stickers
• A pen or marker

Step-By-Step:

1. Sort through your board games and decide which ones you want to sell.
2. Price each game individually using price tags or stickers and a pen or marker. Make sure the price is reasonable and competitive with other sellers.
3. Pack your games in a sturdy box or bag and bring them to the local game store on the day of the annual used sale.
4. Find the designated area for sellers and set up your games on the provided tables or shelves.
5. Be friendly and approachable to potential buyers, but don’t be too pushy. Let them browse and ask questions.
6. Negotiate prices if necessary, but don’t undervalue your games.
7. Keep track of your sales and profits.

Things To Know:

• Arrive early to secure a good spot for your games.
• Research the market value of your games beforehand to ensure you are pricing them appropriately.
• Consider bundling similar games together to increase sales.
• Be prepared to haggle, but don’t sell yourself short.
• Don’t be discouraged if some games don’t sell. You can always try again next year or sell them online.

Option #11. OfferUp

Here’s how to sell gameboards using OfferUp

What You Need:

• A smartphone or tablet with the OfferUp app installed
• High-quality photos of the board games you want to sell
• A detailed description of each game, including any flaws or missing pieces

Step-By-Step:

1. Open the OfferUp app and create an account if you haven’t already.
2. Tap the “Sell” button at the bottom of the screen.
3. Take clear, well-lit photos of each board game you want to sell. Make sure to capture any important details or flaws.
4. Enter a detailed description of each game, including the title, condition, and any missing pieces.
5. Set a fair price for each game based on its condition and rarity.
6. Choose a category for each game (e.g. “Toys & Games” or “Collectibles”).
7. Decide whether you want to offer shipping or local pickup only.
8. Publish your listing and wait for potential buyers to contact you.

Things To Know:

• Be honest about the condition of your board games. Buyers will appreciate your transparency and be more likely to trust you.
• Consider offering bundle deals if you have multiple board games to sell. This can be a great way to attract buyers and move inventory quickly.
• Respond promptly to messages from potential buyers. The faster you can answer their questions and negotiate a price, the more likely they are to buy from you.

Option #12. Mercari

Learn how to sell your board games on Mercari with this step-by-step tutorial.

What You Need:

• A Mercari account
• High-quality photos of your board games
• Accurate descriptions of your board games
• Shipping materials (if you plan to ship the games)

Step-By-Step:

1. Create a listing for your board game by clicking on the “Sell” button on the Mercari app or website.
2. Upload high-quality photos of your board game. Make sure to take photos of the front, back, and sides of the game, as well as any accessories or pieces that come with it.
3. Write an accurate description of your board game. Include the game’s title, condition, any missing pieces, and any other relevant information.
4. Set a price for your board game. Research similar games on Mercari to get an idea of what price to set.
5. Choose your shipping method. You can either offer free shipping or charge the buyer for shipping.
6. Wait for a buyer to purchase your board game. Once a buyer purchases your game, Mercari will send you a shipping label to print and attach to your package.
7. Ship your board game to the buyer.

Things To Know:

• Mercari takes a 10% commission fee on all sales.
• It’s important to accurately describe the condition of your board game to avoid any disputes with the buyer.
• Offering free shipping can make your listing more attractive to buyers.
• Responding to buyer questions and messages in a timely manner can increase your chances of making a sale.

Option #13. Craigslist

Learn how to sell gameboards using Craigslist

What You Need:

• A computer or mobile device with internet access
• High-quality photos of your board games
• A detailed description of each game’s condition, contents, and any missing pieces
• A fair and competitive price for each game

Step-By-Step:

1. Create a Craigslist account or log in to your existing account.
2. Click on the “Post to Classifieds” button on the top left of the homepage.
3. Select the “For Sale” category and then choose “Toys & Games” subcategory.
4. Write a clear and detailed title for your listing, such as “Settlers of Catan Board Game – Like New Condition.”
5. Upload high-quality photos of your board game(s) to the listing.
6. Write a detailed description of the game’s condition, contents, and any missing pieces. Be honest and transparent about the game’s condition to avoid any potential issues with buyers.
7. Set a fair and competitive price for the game(s). Research similar games on Craigslist or other online marketplaces to get an idea of what price range to set.
8. Choose a safe and public location to meet with potential buyers. Avoid meeting at your home or any secluded areas.
9. Respond promptly to any inquiries or offers from potential buyers. Be professional and courteous in all communications.

Things To Know:

• Always prioritize safety when selling on Craigslist. Choose a public location to meet with potential buyers and never give out personal information.
• Be honest and transparent about the condition of your board games to avoid any potential issues with buyers.
• Respond promptly to any inquiries or offers from potential buyers to keep the selling process moving smoothly.

Conclusion

Selling board games can be a lucrative way to make extra cash or clear out clutter. There are many options available, both online and locally. The best thing about any of these platforms is that you can always count on your shared enthusiasm and love for tabletop gaming to help ease transactions with other players. A lot of the mentioned sites and methods above will always have like-minded gamers to get to know and negotiate with, and this social aspect of selling great game boards will always be an extra bonus to look forward to. So, whether you’re a collector looking to thin out your collection or just looking to make some extra cash, selling board games can be a great option. Start exploring your options today and turn your old games into cash!